At a Glance
- Paying a sponsored worker less than the promised salary, without telling the Home Office or where the reduction is not otherwise permitted, is a mandatory ground for revocation. In these cases, the Home Office can revoke a sponsor licence immediately and without warning.
- Treal Care shows that the Home Office must look at the full picture and treat employers fairly. But with record numbers of licences being revoked, prevention is far better than cure.
What Happened in Treal Care?
UK employers who want to hire workers from overseas usually need a "sponsor licence" from the Home Office. The licence comes with ongoing compliance duties and, if the Home Office believes they have been broken, it can impose a range of penalties, from downgrading the licence to suspension or removal (known as "revocation").
Treal Care supplies care workers to the NHS, local councils, and care providers, and employed around 85 people, 75 of whom were sponsored workers under its licence. After a compliance visit in March 2024, the Home Office suspended Treal Care's sponsor licence in August 2024 and revoked it in October 2024. It said that three sponsored workers had been paid less than the £22,400 annual salary they were promised.
Underpayment is a mandatory revocation ground. The Home Office's guidance for sponsors includes a list, known as Annex C1, setting out the circumstances when it will revoke a licence. Pursuant to ground (aa) of Annex C1, paying a sponsored worker less than the promised salary, without telling the Home Office or where the reduction is not otherwise permitted, is a mandatory ground for revocation. In these cases, the Home Office can revoke a sponsor licence immediately and without warning.
Treal Care challenged the revocation in court and won. For each of the three sponsored workers, there was an explanation for the lower pay. The first had taken unpaid leave, which is permitted under the immigration rules but must be reported. The second had not been paid for training hours, but Treal Care paid the shortfall before the revocation. The third had worked reduced hours while caring for her seriously ill son. Treal Care wrongly believed that compassionate leave allowed it to reduce her pay, but it later paid her the full shortfall, so she received the wages she would have earned had she not been on leave. The Home Office never considered these reasons. The High Court overturned the revocation in July 2025, and on November 5, 2026, the Court of Appeal rejected the Home Office's appeal.
What Did the Court Decide?
- Look at the bigger picture: The question is whether the worker is being paid the required annual rate. Where hours vary, the Home Office cannot insist on one-twelfth of the annual salary every month; it must make a rounded assessment over an appropriate period.
- Listen to the employer: Before reaching a conclusion on whether or not to penalise the licence holder, the Home Office should normally give the licence holder an opportunity to respond and, where appropriate, to take remedial action.
- Decisions must be fair: Even where the guidance provides for a mandatory revocation, the Home Office keeps some residual discretion and must properly explain its decisions.
However, the High Court also confirmed that the Home Office can act quickly and firmly when it suspects a problem.
Why This Matters
The decision comes at a time of record enforcement activities. Between July 2024 and June 2025, the Home Office revoked 1,948 sponsor licences, more than double the 937 revoked the year before. By September 2026, the UK government said that more than 7,500 sponsor licences had been revoked in total, including 1,800 in the care sector.
Treal Care demonstrates how small slips can have serious results. The duty to tell the Home Office about changes to a sponsored worker's employment, such as a pay reduction, unpaid leave, or a change in hours, can feel like routine administration. But under the Home Office guidance, failing to report changes on time is itself a ground that will "normally" lead to revocation. If the worker is paid less than promised, the mandatory revocation ground (aa) may also apply. Treal Care had not reported the pay changes at the time.
What Attracts Home Office Attention?
The Home Office monitors sponsors through visits, which can be unannounced, and through information from employers and other government departments, such as HM Revenue & Customs. Things that can attract attention, or lead to suspension or revocation, include:
- Underpaying workers or giving them fewer work hours than promised
- Sponsoring workers for jobs that are not genuine, or more workers than the business needs
- Failing to report changes on time
- High staff turnover, weak recruitment practices, or poor record keeping
- Mistreating or exploiting workers
- Operating in a higher-risk sector, such as adult social care, hospitality, retail, or construction
Revocation is serious. The employer can no longer sponsor anyone, and its sponsored workers may have to find a new employer or leave the UK. The reputational damage to the employer can also be substantial.
There is no right of appeal to a revocation. The only way to challenge a revocation is to ask the High Court for a judicial review, which looks at whether the decision was made lawfully and fairly. Treal Care took this route.
Practical Tips for Employers
- Check pay regularly and keep a note explaining any differences, such as unpaid leave.
- Fix mistakes quickly and record what was done and when. Actions of this nature were helpful to Treal Care in their case.
- Report changes to the Home Office within the required deadlines.
- Keep records showing each job is real, plus payslips and right-to-work checks.
- Take advice early: speaking to an immigration adviser at the first sign of a problem, ideally before responding to the Home Office. This gives you the best chance of resolving concerns.
In conclusion, Treal Care shows that the Home Office must look at the full picture and treat employers fairly. But with record numbers of licences being revoked, prevention is far better than cure.