Class Certification Runs Out of Gas Over Consent Questions

The Northern District of Texas recently denied class certification in Rhonn Mitchell v. Toyota of Dallas, a putative class action arising from allegations that Toyota of Dallas (TOD) had violated the TCPA by sending marketing text messages to customers who had previously opted out of such communications. See 2025 WL 3013789 (N.D. Tex. Oct. 28, 2025). This case illustrates the teeth of the predominance inquiry and the importance of maintaining consent records, which are significant evidence even when held in varying formats.